The Carbon Trading Market: China’s Green Ambitions Forge a New Legal Specialism
I. Introduction
China, a nation at the forefront of global economic development, is increasingly asserting its leadership in the fight against climate change. With ambitious targets for carbon neutrality by 2060, the country has embarked on a transformative journey towards a greener economy. A cornerstone of this strategy is the establishment and rapid expansion of its national carbon trading scheme (ETS). While still in its nascent stages, this market is poised to become the largest in the world, creating an entirely new and highly complex legal specialism. This article posits that law firms and legal professionals who proactively invest in understanding the intricate regulatory landscape of carbon trading, verification processes, and the burgeoning field of green finance will be strategically positioned to dominate a multi-billion dollar market within the next five years. This analysis will delve into the evolution and current state of China’s ETS, examine its foundational legal and regulatory framework, explore its immense market potential and economic implications, highlight the emergence of a distinct legal specialism, and finally, discuss the challenges and future outlook for this pivotal market.
II. The Evolution and Current State of China’s ETS
China’s journey towards a national carbon market began with a series of regional pilot programs launched in 2013 across seven provinces and cities [14]. These pilots, including those in Beijing, Shanghai, and Shenzhen, served as crucial testing grounds, providing invaluable experience in carbon allowance allocation, trading mechanisms, and compliance management. The lessons learned from these regional initiatives paved the way for the establishment of a unified national market.
The national ETS officially commenced operations in July 2021, initially covering the power generation sector, which accounts for over 40% of the country’s total carbon emissions [14]. This strategic focus on a single, high-emitting sector allowed for a more manageable rollout and facilitated the development of robust market infrastructure. Since its launch, the national ETS has demonstrated its capacity to reduce carbon intensity, with pilot ETSs showing even more pronounced effects [11].
Recent developments underscore China’s commitment to expanding and strengthening its carbon market. In April 2025, China officially announced the expansion of its national ETS to include the cement, steel, and aluminum sectors, with the first compliance deadline scheduled for the end of 2025 [7, 9]. This expansion significantly broadens the market’s coverage, bringing more industrial emitters under its regulatory umbrella. Furthermore, in 2024, China relaunched its domestic offsetting scheme, the Chinese Certified Emissions Reduction (CCER) scheme, after a six-year suspension for reform [8]. The CCER scheme allows companies to generate tradable credits from emission reduction projects outside the ETS, providing additional flexibility for compliance and stimulating investment in a wider range of green initiatives.
III. The Legal and Regulatory Framework of China’s ETS
The legal foundation of China’s national ETS has been significantly bolstered by the promulgation of the “Interim Regulations for the Management of Carbon Emissions Trading” by the State Council in January 2024, which officially took effect on May 1, 2024 [1, 2, 3, 4, 6]. These regulations represent China’s first dedicated national-level legislation for carbon emissions trading, providing a comprehensive legal basis for the market’s operation.
The Interim Regulations define the scope and coverage of the ETS, outlining the industries and entities subject to compliance obligations. They establish the principles for carbon emission allowance (CEA) allocation, which can be either free or auctioned, and detail the monitoring, reporting, and verification requirements for covered entities. Crucially, the regulations also specify the enforcement mechanisms and penalties for non-compliance, aiming to deter violations and ensure market integrity. For instance, entities failing to meet their compliance obligations may face fines, public exposure, and even suspension of trading activities.
Despite these advancements, certain legal ambiguities persist, particularly concerning the precise legal nature of CEAs and CCERs. While these instruments are central to the trading scheme, their classification under existing statutes in China is not yet explicitly addressed [13]. This lack of specific legal definition can create uncertainties regarding property rights, collateralization, and dispute resolution, posing challenges for market participants and legal practitioners alike. The legal governance of the carbon market involves both private and public law principles, with private law addressing rights and obligations in trading, and public law setting the framework for emissions limits and enforcement [12]. Clarifying these aspects will be crucial for the long-term stability and growth of the market.
IV. Market Potential and Economic Implications
The sheer scale of China’s economy and its commitment to decarbonization position its ETS to become the largest carbon market in the world. This immense scale translates into significant market potential and profound economic implications, not only for China but also for global climate finance.
The market’s expansion to include heavy industries like cement, steel, and aluminum will dramatically increase the volume of traded allowances and the overall market value. This growth will create a multi-billion dollar market, attracting substantial investment in carbon assets, trading platforms, and ancillary services. The development of a robust carbon market also fosters innovation in low-carbon technologies and energy efficiency, as companies seek cost-effective ways to reduce their emissions and meet compliance targets.
Furthermore, China’s carbon market is deeply interconnected with the broader green finance agenda. The ETS provides a tangible price signal for carbon, incentivizing financial institutions to channel capital towards environmentally friendly projects and sustainable investments. Green bonds, green loans, and other sustainable financial products are increasingly linked to carbon performance, creating a symbiotic relationship between the carbon market and the green finance ecosystem. This integration is vital for mobilizing the massive capital required for China’s green transition and achieving its climate goals.
V. The Emergence of a New Legal Specialism
The complexity and rapid evolution of China’s carbon trading market are giving rise to a distinct and highly specialized legal field. As companies navigate the intricate web of regulations, compliance requirements, and market dynamics, the demand for expert legal guidance is escalating rapidly. This new specialism encompasses a wide array of legal services, requiring a deep understanding of environmental law, financial regulations, and international trade principles.
Key areas of demand for specialized legal expertise include:
- Regulatory Compliance and Advisory: Legal professionals are essential for advising covered entities on their obligations under the ETS, including emissions monitoring, reporting, and verification. This involves interpreting complex regulations, assisting with allowance allocation applications, and ensuring adherence to compliance deadlines.
- Transactional Law: The trading of carbon credits, offsets, and derivatives necessitates specialized legal support. Lawyers will be involved in drafting and negotiating trading agreements, structuring carbon finance deals, and advising on the legal implications of various carbon market instruments.
- Dispute Resolution: As the market matures, disputes related to carbon trading, such as those concerning allowance allocation, verification discrepancies, or contractual breaches, are inevitable. Legal experts will be needed for arbitration, litigation, and other forms of dispute resolution within this specialized context.
- Due Diligence for Green Investments: With the growing emphasis on green finance, legal professionals will play a crucial role in conducting due diligence for investments in low-carbon projects, assessing environmental risks, and ensuring compliance with green financing standards.
- Corporate Governance and ESG Reporting: Companies are increasingly facing pressure to integrate environmental, social, and governance (ESG) considerations into their corporate strategies. Lawyers specializing in carbon markets can advise on ESG reporting requirements, climate-related disclosures, and the integration of carbon performance into corporate governance frameworks.
Legal professionals entering this field will require a multidisciplinary skill set, combining traditional legal acumen with a strong grasp of environmental science, economics, and financial markets. Law firms that proactively develop expertise in these areas, offering comprehensive services from regulatory advisory to transactional support and dispute resolution, are strategically positioning themselves to capture a significant share of this burgeoning market.
VI. Challenges and Future Outlook
Despite its promising trajectory, China’s national ETS faces several challenges that will need to be addressed for its continued success and maturation.
One significant challenge lies in data accuracy and verification. The integrity of a carbon market relies heavily on the precise and verifiable reporting of emissions data. Ensuring consistent and reliable MRV across a vast and diverse industrial base remains a complex undertaking. Efforts to strengthen data quality and verification processes are ongoing, but continuous improvement is essential to maintain market credibility.
Another challenge pertains to market liquidity and price volatility. While the market is growing, achieving optimal liquidity and stable carbon prices will require further refinement of trading mechanisms, increased participation, and potentially the introduction of more sophisticated financial instruments. Price volatility can create uncertainty for businesses and hinder long-term investment in decarbonization.
Furthermore, the harmonization with international carbon markets presents both an opportunity and a challenge. As China’s ETS matures, aligning its standards and mechanisms with global carbon markets could facilitate international carbon trading and enhance global climate cooperation. However, differences in regulatory approaches and market designs will need to be carefully navigated.
Finally, the evolving regulatory landscape itself poses a challenge. The rapid pace of policy development and market adjustments requires continuous adaptation from market participants and legal professionals. Staying abreast of new regulations, policy directives, and enforcement trends is crucial for effective engagement with the ETS.
Looking ahead, the future of China’s ETS appears to be one of continued expansion, stronger enforcement, and deeper alignment with the nation’s broader environmental and energy policies [10, 15]. The recent guideline issued by China to advance low-carbon transition explicitly calls for expanding the coverage of the national carbon trading market and improving the carbon emission quota allocation system [15]. This indicates a clear policy direction towards strengthening the market’s role in achieving climate goals. China’s proactive stance in developing its carbon market also positions it as a key player in global climate governance, potentially influencing international carbon pricing mechanisms and fostering greater global cooperation on climate action.
VII. Conclusion
China’s national carbon trading scheme is a monumental undertaking, reflecting the nation’s unwavering commitment to a green and sustainable future. From its foundational pilot programs to its current status as a rapidly expanding national market, the ETS is transforming China’s economic and environmental landscape. It is not merely a mechanism for emissions reduction but a powerful engine for economic restructuring, technological innovation, and the development of a sophisticated green finance ecosystem. The complexity and dynamism of this market have unequivocally forged a new and vital legal specialism. For law firms and legal professionals, the imperative is clear: to proactively develop expertise in the regulatory intricacies of carbon trading, verification, and green finance. Those who invest in this understanding now will not only contribute to China’s green ambitions but will also secure a dominant position in a multi-billion dollar market that is set to define the future of environmental law and sustainable business.
References
[1] China strengthens legal foundation for national ETS. (2024, February 23). ICAP Carbon Action. https://icapcarbonaction.com/en/news/china-strengthens-legal-foundation-national-ets
[2] China National ETS. ICAP Carbon Action. https://icapcarbonaction.com/en/ets/china-national-ets
[3] China releases carbon emissions trading regulations. (2024, February 4). english.www.gov.cn. https://english.www.gov.cn/policies/latestreleases/202402/04/content_WS65bf7f70c6d0868f4e8e3c94.html
[4] Progress Report of China’s National Carbon Market (2024). (2024, July 14). mee.gov.cn. https://www.mee.gov.cn/ywdt/xwfb/202407/W020240722528850763859.pdf
[5] Legal regulation of China’s carbon emissions trading market. (2025, September 23). frontiersin.org. https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/environmental-science/articles/10.3389/fenvs.2025.1604038/pdf
[6] China Releases Carbon Allowance Trading Regulations. (2024, February 28). lw.com. https://www.lw.com/admin/upload/SiteAttachments/China-Releases-Carbon-Allowance-Trading-Regulations.pdf
[7] China officially expands national ETS to cement, steel and …. (2025, April 10). ICAP Carbon Action. https://icapcarbonaction.com/en/news/china-officially-expands-national-ets-cement-steel-and-aluminum-sectors
[8] ETS Status: China. Asia Society Policy Institute. https://asiasociety.org/policy-institute/ets-status-china
[9] China. Climate Action Tracker. https://climateactiontracker.org/countries/china/
[10] Can China’s ETS Push the World Toward a Green Future? (2025, June 13). kleinmanenergy.upenn.edu. https://kleinmanenergy.upenn.edu/commentary/blog/can-chinas-ets-push-the-world-toward-a-green-future/
[11] The effectiveness of China’s national emissions trading …. sciencedirect.com. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0140988325006565
[12] Full article: The legal governance of the carbon market. tandfonline.com. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/17583004.2023.2288591
[13] Carbon trading in China: key considerations for navigating …. (2024, July 25). cgj.hkcgi.org.hk. https://cgj.hkcgi.org.hk/carbon-trading-china-key-considerations-navigating-schemes
[14] The Carbon Emissions Trading Policy of China. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9658961/
[15] China issues guideline to advance low-carbon transition …. (2025, August 25). english.www.gov.cn. https://english.www.gov.cn/policies/latestreleases/202508/25/content_WS68ac6afac6d0868f4e8f50fc.html
